The Volunteer Vigilantes of New York City (2024)

Since their heyday 40 years ago, the Guardian Angels have become a figment of New Yorkers’ collective memory. The volunteer vigilante squad, led by Curtis Sliwa, was a mainstay in the city in the late 1970s and ’80s—a period when the police department coined the moniker “Fear City” for the five boroughs and warned tourists not to go out after sunset.

The charismatic and controversial Sliwa trained his red-capped followers—mostly young people of color from troubled neighborhoods—to patrol the streets and subways. At the time, crime was high: The rates of murder, theft, and assault all roughly doubled between 1965 and 1975. And by the mid-1970s, the police force was thinned out because of a fiscal crisis facing the city. The troupe’s stated aim was to protect citizens and deter wrongdoing, and they’d physically fight individuals they deemed a threat.

But the Guardian Angels, and Sliwa himself, were not without critics, who said the members were inadequately trained, ineffective, and behaved no better than local gangs did. The most prominent critic was former Mayor Ed Koch, who accused Sliwa of being more interested in fame than stopping criminals. That accusation was partially corroborated in 1992 when Sliwa, whose group by then had expanded internationally, admitted to faking multiple crimes for publicity—a decision he’s since said he regrets.

New York City is a wholly different town today: Crime rates are at historic lows and a crisis of gentrification has largely replaced that of urban blight. But to Sliwa, the Guardian Angels are still relevant, even if their ranks in New York are a shadow of what they once were. Last year, he found a reason to call his followers back to service: a series of subway slashings that then-NYPD Commissioner William Bratton called an “aberration.” “There’s an aggressiveness that’s taking place in the subways that hasn’t taken place for quite some time,” Sliwa told Time. “My sense over the years is that we’re beginning to slip back.”

In hyping those events, Sliwa seems to be aiming for a Guardian Angels resurgence. His current focus is the subway system, which he claims is a dangerous place for women specifically. I spoke with Sliwa recently about his motivations; his legacy; and a new documentary, Vigilante, that chronicles his career, mostly through his own perspective. The conversation that follows, held over two phone calls, has been edited and condensed for clarity.

Maura Ewing: First, the red beret: You are wearing it in every scene. Is that your everyday attire?

Curtis Sliwa: It’s like an appendage to my head. People think that I sleep with it.

Ewing: Do you?

Sliwa: Sometimes I do. I actually pull it over my head and it blocks out the light and I catch a few zzz’s. You can do everything with that red beret.

Ewing: What’s the current status of the Guardian Angels? Are you patrolling?

Sliwa: We’re in 13 countries, 130 cities. We have an international membership of about 5,000. The main focus is always going to be the patrol. We also have ancillary things that we do now—for instance, we have Junior Guardian Angels. These are young girls, young boys, who are six to 15 years old. They do not patrol—we teach them martial arts. This way they can protect themselves, it teaches them discipline, and it gives them self-esteem. They also do community service.

Most recently I’ve spent a lot of time on two new groups. One is called the Perv Busters. It’s mostly women who patrol. The program has had just a year in existence in New York City; now we’re going to try to roll it out in some of our other chapters. They go after the [men] exposing themselves on the subways—very similar to what we’ve seen a lot of well-to-do guys be accused of and acknowledge, like the comedian Louis C.K. [These men] collect in mass transit because it’s easy for them to rub up against women and violate women, particularly during rush hour.

Often, we are provided pictures of them that victims took with their cellphones. We’ll do informational outreach in which we print up thousands of flyers and spread them throughout the system and then immediately begin pursuing them—something the local authorities just don’t do. It’s almost like out of sight, out of mind.

Ewing: With Perv Busters, are you trying to catch people in the act?

Sliwa: We have, but it’s not the main focus. The predators underground in the subways are creatures of habit. They will ride the same trains at the same times, normally at peak hours, because if a woman objects to him [touching] her or accosting her, he can claim, “Oh, it’s so crowded here, I’m sorry.” We get their photographs, and we begin to hunt them. We have had some arrested, but it’s mostly an informational campaign.

Ewing: Do you ever worry that you’re going after an innocent person?

Sliwa: Of course. The checks and balances are that you don’t act like Donald Trump and retweet something. You do due-diligence forensic research [to see] if you can come up with a name, an identity, other people who will likewise indicate that this person has been molesting women in the area. We’ve been doing this for over a year-and-a-half. We’ve probably leafletted 185 [men]. None of it has come back to haunt us because we didn’t dot the i’s and cross the t’s.

Ewing: How do you do your research?

Sliwa: We try to go online, see if there are other women who likewise have seen this guy, or if he fits a description. A lot of times women will take pictures of these guys—you make sure it’s not Photoshopped. If enough women have come forward and have IDed the guy and he seems to have a certain pattern, then we go with it without police verification.

Ewing: What is enough?

Sliwa: Enough is three or more people who have IDed the guy who aren’t friends with each other and not related—independent sources.

Ewing: Is Perv Busters legal?

Sliwa: It’s legal. But if you ID the wrong person, you yourself can be arrested because, remember, we have no special powers or privileges.

Ewing: Your group started patrolling the subways again in New York City about a year ago—is that right?

Sliwa: No, we have patrolled regularly since 1979. We’ve had patrols every day and every night since we began. But nowhere near to the effect that we had between 1979 and 1993, which is the period that the documentary covers.

Ewing: I read in a Time story that you came back last year because of a series of slashings on the subway.

Sliwa: That’s true. We doubled down, we increased our recruitment, and we began to focus on those neighborhoods that were the feeding system for the slashings. They weren’t taking place all over the subway system, but were in certain key junction areas, particularly up to Harlem, Washington Heights, Inwood, the South Bronx, and parts of Brooklyn. The NYPD didn’t seem to have an answer to it at the time, so we helped to fill the void. [The NYPD did not reply to a request for comment on this story, and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority declined to comment on Sliwa’s campaign in the subways.]

People will get in contact with us if they haven’t gotten relief from first going to the police. We’re always the last choice that a person has when they’re frustrated because they’ve tried all other measures, and they figure they’ve got nothing to lose. The Perv Busters is a classic example: Every time we’re on the subway, we have women coming up, showing us pictures on their cellphones. We always ask, “Did you take it to the police?” They say, “Yeah.” “What happened?” “Nothing.”

Obviously, we were more needed in the ’70s when they were laying off cops because the city was in fiscal distress. [In 1974] the city announced that at night there would be no more uniformed police patrolling [in the subway] during the off-peak hours, 7 p.m. to 5 a.m. That was a license to steal for thugs. You don’t have that situation now. The police are fully staffed and they generally do a pretty good job. But there are still those pockets out there, situations that they chose not to get involved in. Or they’ve tried some methods and are just not successful. Or they don’t seem to understand the problem.

Ewing: It seems like you have an interest in convincing the public that crime is coming back. Is that an element of your approach?

Sliwa: No, I wouldn’t say it is.

Ewing: But in New York, your group reemerged after the slashings. I read that you were convinced the city’s slipping back. Is it part of your approach to tell people the city is getting more dangerous?

Sliwa: Definitely in the subways, the number of [reported] sexual assaults and sexual harassments has gone up each of the past two years by 20 percent. It’s a major problem in the subway system, along with crime in general in the subway, whereas you can’t really make the same case aboveground. But, still, it’s a much better system than what we were introduced into when anarchy reigned between 1979 and 1992 in the subways.

Ewing: The new documentary alleges that you contributed to the decline of crime in the ’90s. How?

Sliwa: There were three ways that we contributed: First, we destroyed the stereotype that existed in our city that young black and Latino men or women coming out of the hood had a predisposition to join gangs and be thugs or thugettes. That was a very prevalent stereotype. But here emerges the Guardian Angels, predominately black or Hispanic young people who were a total contrast to the gangs.

Secondly, we had a fight-back mentality. The acronym very common then was MYOB: Mind your own business. You had a lot of lawyers out there threatening to sue people, like us, who got physically involved. We spit in their eye and defied that.

The last thing was that we proved that one woman or one man could make a difference in a neighborhood. All it took was one person to start organizing; he or she could make a difference. You just had to do the heavy lifting and the hard work and know that change would come in slow increments.

Ewing: Some counter theories to why crime declined are that there was economic growth in the ’90s and more people were incarcerated—what do you think about that?

Sliwa: Birthrate, that’s another factor. I personally believe a lot of it had to do with an enormous drop in the youth population. All of those factors played in, too.

Ewing: Initially, how did you get community members to trust the Guardian Angels?

Sliwa: They were coming from poor and impoverished neighborhoods; they were fed up; they wanted to fight back but needed a vehicle and mechanism to do that. It’s very hard to do that on your own.

The Volunteer Vigilantes of New York City (2024)

FAQs

Who are the vigilantes in New York City? ›

The Guardian Angels is a non-profit international volunteer organization with the goal of unarmed crime prevention. The Guardian Angels organization was founded on February 13, 1979, in New York City, by Curtis Sliwa. Since then, it has expanded to more than 130 cities and 13 countries worldwide.

Do Guardian Angels still exist in New York? ›

The Guardian Angels have been a fixture in New York City since 1979, when Sliwa founded the group to patrol the streets and subways during the city's high-crime days. Members have drawn criticism, including allegations of targeting people of color.

How do the Guardian Angels make money? ›

The Guardian Angels Fund relies primarily on individual donations from employees and support from Guardian Pharmacy Management Services, LLC to fund this program. Every contribution helps and when combined with the donations of others, can provide the help a fellow employee needs when facing the unexpected.

What is the documentary about Curtis Sliwa? ›

The incredible story of a man, a mission, and an organization that transcended race and gender to save New York City from a pit of despair in the late 1970's and 1980's.

Who was the famous New York vigilante? ›

Bernhard Goetz (born November 7, 1947, Queens, New York, U.S.) is an American vigilante who rose to national fame when he shot four African American males on a New York City subway train on December 22, 1984. The event was notable for triggering widespread debate about race and crime in America.

Who are some real life vigilantes? ›

M
  • Stephen Marshall (murderer)
  • Daniel Boone May.
  • Richard McCaslin.
  • Sherman McMaster.
  • Frank McNab.
  • John Middleton (cowboy)

Do the Guardian Angels carry guns? ›

Our unarmed patrols have made over 800 citizens' arrests and our very presence has deterred countless others. We have demonstrated that people of all races and ethnic groups can work together to improve our communities for everyone.

How do I know who is my guardian angel? ›

According to the day and month you were born you can find out who is the angel who takes care of your path. There are a total of 72 angels for the 12 months of the year and each of us has one, who guides and helps to resist in life. Which is your guardian angel according to the day you were born.

Who is the leader of the Guardian Angels in New York? ›

Curtis Sliwa (/ˈsliwə/; born March 26, 1954) is an American activist, radio talk show host, and founder and chief executive officer of the Guardian Angels, a nonprofit crime prevention organization.

What religion is Guardian Angels from? ›

The belief that everyone has a guardian angel is a dogma of the Christian faith, dating even back to the belief of the Jews during the Old and New Testaments. Matthew 18:10 (NIV), in particular, gives us evidence of guardian angels: See that you do not despise one of these little ones.

How many Guardian Angels have been killed? ›

Since the group began patrolling in 1979, three Angels have been killed, one of them shot by mistake by Newark police. Authorities in other cities where Angels have patrolled simply brush them off as publicity hounds.

How much are the angels worth today? ›

Despite this relative lack of recent success, the Angels are worth an estimated US$2.2 billion according to Forbes' most recent rankings – placing then ninth in the league. However, Moreno has now decided to end the exploratory process to sell the team and will continue as owner throughout the 2023 season and beyond.

Do the Guardian Angels still exist? ›

The Guardian Angels, a crime patrol organization from the 70's offers insight into the future of community policing. The Guardian Angels are back in full force in NYC with their signature red berets and bomber jackets emblazoned with a masonic eye.

Is The Guardian Angels movie based on a true story? ›

Vigilante: The Incredible True Story of Curtis Sliwa and the Guardian Angels - Full Cast & Crew. Frustrated with the increasing rate of crime in 1970s New York, Curtis Sliwa and his fast-food restaurant colleagues decided to take citizen safety into their own hands - forming 'The Guardian Angels'.

What is the movie about the Guardian Angels NYC? ›

VIGILANTE: THE INCREDIBLE TRUE STORY OF CURTIS SLIWA AND THE GUARDIAN ANGELS.

Who were the vigilantes and what did they do? ›

Vigilantism (/vɪdʒɪˈlæntɪzəm/) is the act of preventing, investigating, and punishing perceived offenses and crimes without legal authority. A vigilante is a person who practices or partakes in vigilantism, or undertakes public safety and retributive justice without commission.

Who are the biggest crime bosses in New York? ›

Original and current Five Families bosses
Original family nameFounded byNamed after
ProfaciJoe ProfaciJoseph Colombo
ManganoVincent ManganoCarlo Gambino
LucianoLucky LucianoVito Genovese
GaglianoTommy GaglianoTommy Lucchese
1 more row

Who is considered a vigilante? ›

A vigilante is a person who claims to enforce law and order by their own initiative but lacks legal authority to do so. Vigilantes operate by using actual or threatened force and are distinguished from people who simply watch out for criminal behavior and report it to the police.

Is vigilantism illegal in New York? ›

Vigilantism is not legal. You have no authority to act as a police officer, judge or jury. That's what it is.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Moshe Kshlerin

Last Updated:

Views: 5713

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Moshe Kshlerin

Birthday: 1994-01-25

Address: Suite 609 315 Lupita Unions, Ronnieburgh, MI 62697

Phone: +2424755286529

Job: District Education Designer

Hobby: Yoga, Gunsmithing, Singing, 3D printing, Nordic skating, Soapmaking, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Moshe Kshlerin, I am a gleaming, attractive, outstanding, pleasant, delightful, outstanding, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.